Wheeling & dealing in the selection of the 2009-2014 Cabinet, foreign plants & political hacks.
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono announced his second United Indonesia Cabinet on 21st October, the portfolios and ministers divided into relevant sections:
Coordinating
Departmental
State
Other
Three other roles which saw no change and were not announced formally: Attorney General (Hendarman Supandji), Chief of Staff (Djoko Santoso) and Police Chief (General Bambang Hendarso Danuri).
For harmony and balance the list includes one Papuan (Freddie Numberi), one ethnic Chinese (Mari Elka Pangestu), one Balinese (Jero Wacik), one Minahasan (E.E. Mangindaan), with these names also making up the bulk of the non-Muslim contingent, which also includes the Javanese Catholic Purnomo Yusgiantoro. thejakartapost
Purnomo Yusgiantoro
Broken down by island the composition is Java 22, Sumatra 11 (5 Minang), Sulawesi 4, Bali, Papua and Kalimantan one each.
Politically twenty among the appointments are from coalition parties (the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS), the National Mandate Party (PAN), the United Development Party (PPP), National Awakening Party (PKB) and Golkar).
Some foreign observers expressed disappointment in the choices, that they were conventional and lacklustre, and included too few reformers and too many political/factional appointments without any real experience in their portfolio areas.
The Economist praised the retaining of technocrats such as Sri Mulyani Indrawati in Finance and Mari Pangestu in Trade, while deploring the selection of Purnomo Yusgiantoro in Defence, the latter said to have had a poor reputation in his past Energy portfolio. economist
Endang Rahayu Sedyaningsih
While a local observer, Agung Nugroho from ‘Dewan Kesehatan Rakyat’, received much media attention when he complained that Endang Rahayu Sedyaningsih won the Health portfolio at the insistence of foreign governments, because unlike her predecessor Siti Fadilah Supari she would not struggle to develop public health services, and that she was on record as approving of the American government owned Namru laboratory in Jakarta. matanews
Nila Djuwita Anfasah Moeloek was the 1st candidate for Health Minister. reported that she failed in fit and proper test. Complete news on her failure can be read here.
Endang was graduated from Harvard University, perhaps that is also the reason for SBY to choose her instead of Nila.
Somehow I think the cabinet is too big and it looks ineffective & chaotic.
I would combine Youth issue under Education or Manpower. While Womens’ Empowerment & Child Protection would be ideally under Justice & Human Rights since all related problem in regards to women & children are strongly related to bias gender regulation & law plus weak law enforcement. I have never understood what Public Works ministry does *anyone can please tell me???* I think Disadvantaged Regions, Public Housing, Transmigration issue could be under National Development Planning ..aaargghh it’s so chaotic..what are the aims of this cabinet?? From its composition, it looks like this cabinet will cost overlapping assignment!
I have found everyone’s comments very interesting and enlighting. I am a student in the US and working on a research paper. Can someone tell me the best internet place to locate information for my paper. I am researching “Women Leaders of Indonesia”.
Thanks
Copyright Indonesia Matters 2006-2023
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact
Thanks Patung – this is a good one stop summary.