Lombok expat Gregory Luke jailed for blasphemous tampering with mosque sound systems.
American guesthouse owner Gregory Lloyd Luke, 64 years old, was sentenced to five months prison after being convicted of two counts of blasphemy and one of disorderly conduct at the Praya District Court in Lombok yesterday.
On August 22nd 2010 Luke had angrily pulled out the plug of a sound system in a mosque near his home in Kuta, Lombok, after complaining that a prayer reading being held was too loud and distorted. Local residents then became angry with him, went to his home and ransacked it, causing about 200 million rupiah damage; no-one has been prosecuted for this crime. Luke was later arrested and charged with blasphemy.
Initially after being arrested Luke denied that he had pulled out the plug, but in court he confessed to the deed. Prosecutors had sought a 7 month term for Luke, far less than the maximum 5 years, but Judge Suhartoyo said there were mitigating factors, they being that he:
Luke, who wore a sarong, polo shirt and peci at the hearing, said in his plea for mercy:
I apologise for my wrongdoing in the mosque. I’ve followed all the trial proceedings and listened to the witnesses’ testimonies. I hope I can get the lightest sentence.
Neither the prosecution nor the defence intends to challenge any part of the verdict or sentencing.
Oh yea, nearly forgot, someone should link to Timdog’s excellent analysis of Lombok’s doctrinaire Islam posted over on RRA.
He was an idiot and probably realises that fact now.
Don’t like large crowds of football fans? Don’t choose to live near Old Trafford. Object to girls wearing skimpy bikinis? Best to avoid a house by Copacabana beach. Hate the screechy sound of badly tuned mosque loudspeakers during Ramadan? Well a devoutly Islamic island in a largely Muslim archipelago might not be the best choice for a retirement home.
Noise pollution is an almost universal evil in SEAsia. In most of the Philippines it is not the mosques but the neighbourhood Karaoke Bars (and the neighbour’s karaoke), the open air “discos” and numerous fiestas. The speakers used are always of a monstrous size. It is not uncommon to see a five foot Filipino lugging around a six foot speaker.
However, I suppose that what makes mosques particularly troublesome is the early hours at which they are bound to start their noise eruptions. Joseph Conrad, in referring to the sorry lot of pilgrims on “Lord Jim’s” ship, talks about their “exacting” faith. A nice neutral term – covering all kinds of ills including sleep deprivation.
Sometimes I dream of playing Christian rock on a massive sound system at 5 in the morning in the middle of a Jakarta neighbourhood…
I think foreigners should respect the local culture. G Luke should find another country that he considers appropriate with him. In fact Indonesia is a rich country does not need foreigners to interfere. Especially want to change their culture.
I feel for Mr. Luke. I am a devout Muslim, and even I get irritated by those loud prayers over terrible sound systems, regardless the time they air it.
He was probably at wits end, and all he wanted to have was a quiet peaceful start of a day.
Surely disconnecting a plug from a sound system is not blasphemic.
And isn’t it shameful that the people who vandalised his house didn’t have to be held responsible?
This is more than just blasphemy accusation, or disorderly conduct. What had happened to him is just pure hatred. The subtext of this mishap is racism.
If I had been the one pulling the plug off a sound system in a mosque, the matter would settle quickly as soon as they name me : the ungrateful snobbish little bitch who lives next door.
What a pity. He might deserve some financial penalty, but not months in jail.
I am muslim, but I hate the mentality most muslim in Indonesia. They should banned loudspeaker in mosques. They are very annoying!
He should have asked the politely. It could have been avoided.
Hello David,
It is common in Malaysian mosque to blast the speaker early in the morning. And it is also considered blasphomous here if anybody complain about the amplitude of the wave. Leave alone walking into a mosque and unplugging the stereo before the songs reach the chorus.
However, those vandalising Mr. Gregory’s retreat will endup in jail if they practice the same street justice here.
read more of this comment here:
http://aderberani.blogspot.com/2011/01/komen-kepada-gregory-luke.html
“This crime called blasphemy was invented by priests for the purpose of defending doctrines not able to take care of themselves”
– Robert Green Ingersoll
Hopefully Muslims will, one day, feel their religious beliefs are strong enough to stand up to criticism rather than suppress other views by violent means.
What irks me the most is the “mitigating circumstances”… so the judge is saying that since the defendant is a Muslim he will get more leniency, thus, logically, if he were not a Muslim, then he would get a fuller sentence. I am not Indonesian, are there two systems of justice? One for Muslims, and an apparently harsher one for non-Muslims? Indonesians do not see this statement as a problem? Wow. In the USA, a judge did the same thing, referring to how good a Christian the defendant in the case was, so leniency
was due. The judge got a bit of tongue lashing for that, and might face inquiry. All citizens should
be treated equally under any legal system, in any country in this world!!
Punish one, but the mob is allowed to go free? Vigilantism is okay too in Indonesia? If it were Christians sacking a Muslim mans house for pulling the plug, you do not thing that they would be charged with a crime? I thought Indonesia was not the same as Pakistan or someplace. I have traveled to Indonesia a few times and I thought it was a more moderate and fair country, I guess I was wrong. So much for going to see beautiful Lombok. I might inadvertently do something “blasphemous” and get lynched by a mob 🙂 who will later be cheered rather than punished. What a world we live in.
Ransacking his house was an over-reaction. After the ransacking, he has been way over-punished, he doesn’t deserve a single night in jail after that.
I keep on wondering what happened before the reported incident. I wouldn’t be surprised if there were aready tensions between Gregory Luke and the community surrounding his guesthouse. Things like this hardly ever happen just out of the blue.
Haha.. thanks, Chris! I sooo much love Monty Phython in this context :-))
I admire Switzerland for standing up and prohibiting its minarettes from bothering every citizien. I CAN`T make noise inside my appartment cause the neighbours may complain to the police, but the mosque can?? At 5am before I have to go to work 12 hours from 8am without a rest? Freedom of religion! Thank god..
Copyright Indonesia Matters 2006-2023
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact
I could be very mistaken but I think Syria doesn’t permit loud speakers expounding from Majid. Maybe that’s why it wasn’t included on the ‘Axis of Evil’ A-list.