You must be logged in to post

Am I a 'bule'?

UserPost

7:10
Mar 4


embryofields

Santri

posts 12

1

hi guys, how are you all ?


was hoping that you could help me out with something that has been bugging me ever since i came across some of the articles on this website, and of course tidakmasalah's infamous 'help a clueless bule' post.


to wit;


am i a 'bule' ?


whilst i was born and raised in the UK, my family are originally from Kashmir, so we're muslim, and of course naturally tanned.  how would i be viewed if i was to visit indonesia ?


thanks in advance peeps

15:37
Mar 4


Patung

Admin

posts 278

2

Yes and no. 'Bule' means 'albino' so there's your 'no'. But I think many people will use it despite its etymological or basic origins in the sense of 'westerner' so that would include you, assuming you act and talk like a westerner does, whatever that means.....

14:39
Mar 7


Farah

Santri

posts 48

3

well.. bule in my concept is caucasian people (men or women). That wont affect anything here tho.. people only see you as foreigner.

1:06
Mar 10


embryofields

Santri

posts 12

4

hmm, i'm a little disappointed about that now.  it would have been nice to treated as one of the locals, rather than being labelled as a foreigner.


so is there any kind of particular way that asian people are viewed, as different to white/westerners who visit ?  my own experience of this was when i was in oman last year, where i was always mistaken as an overseas worker from the sub-continent, instead of being from britain

8:04
Mar 12


Farah

Santri

posts 48

5

embryofields said:

hmm, i'm a little disappointed about that now.  it would have been nice to treated as one of the locals, rather than being labelled as a foreigner.


so is there any kind of particular way that asian people are viewed, as different to white/westerners who visit ?  my own experience of this was when i was in oman last year, where i was always mistaken as an overseas worker from the sub-continent, instead of being from britain


well.. your outlook would be different than locals for sure... some of us will treat you no different, but most people will..


20:52
Mar 17


embryofields

Santri

posts 12

6

sorry to keep asking you guys things, but

is there any kind of pecking order within the ranks of 'bule' or foreigners ?  say americans come top, then australians then british or something  ??

21:17
Mar 17


Suryo Perkoso

Santri

posts 61

7

Oh my word no, it is nothing like that dear boy. All done on a merit basis.

21:07
Mar 23


Aluang Anak Bayang

Abangan

posts 5

8

Quote "… my family are originally from Kashmir, so we’re muslim, and of course naturally tanned …. my own experience of this was when i was in oman last year, where i was always mistaken as an overseas worker from the sub-continent, instead of being from britain …" Unquote.

Patung or Farah. I completely disagree with you two because South East Asians know how to differentiate between orang putih and orang India.  See above underlined.  Embryofields is an Indian.  I am sure he has curry recipe hiding somewhere.

In Indonesia, those who bobble their head while talking and hail from the Indian subcontinent are called kuli or tambi  (whether they are from Pakistan, Ceylon, Bangladesh, Nepal or Kashmir).  In neighbouring Brunei, Malaysia and Singapore, you will be called keling or kelingkia. However, to be polite, you will called ‘orang India’.

Quote "is there any kind of pecking order within the ranks of 'bule' or foreigners ?  say americans come top, then australians then british or something  ??" Unquote.

Indians are well-received in Indonesia.  They are our ancient trading partners, and we have adopted much of Hindu culture.  There is no ranking order for foreigners.  Of the expats, the whincing Bules would like to have preferential treatment, unfortunately Javanese see everyone as equal.

21:18
Mar 23


Patung

Admin

posts 278

9

Oh gawd now we can see you up close....I strongly doubt embroyofields acts like an Indian, bobbing head and all, funny accent, I bet he acts like a lad from the UK....

22:01
Mar 23


Aluang Anak Bayang

Abangan

posts 5

10

Patung, we are talking about appearance.  Consider this analogy.

An ABC (American Born Chinese) speaks and acts like a yankie.  If he come to Indonesia, he will be cina because of his facial features and skin tone.  If he don't speak and act like bule, we will call him 'westernised Chinese'.

Same case as with embryofields, he will still be tambi or keling, but a westernised one.

SE Asians had lived with the Indians for centuries, you can throw an Indian in a crowd of Arabs and Whiteys; any Indonesian, Singaporean or Malaysian can pick him out without much effort.

I have a friend of a friend who was Kuwaiti born.  The first time I met him, he insisted he is Arab (100% Arabs).  He may fool northern Asians and whiteys, but not me.  Finally his wife confided to my wife that he is of Indian heritage but do not like to be regarded as Indian.

3:32
Mar 24


Lairedion

Santri

posts 32

11

"In Indonesia, those who bobble their head while talking"

Aja ngono, Mas. Embryofields might want to visit Indonesia. If you speak so high about Javanese culture why not try to be more polite?

Embryofields, I don't understand your wish to be treated as a local. Just because of your brown skin and religion? You're a Brit of Kashmiri descent. That means you have to tell your background story more often. Accept it.

11:50
Mar 24


Burung Koel

Santri

posts 23

12

That means you have to tell your background story more often. Accept it.

On my first visit to Indonesia (over 25 years ago), I had to explain to everyone that, despite my appearance, I actually couldn't breakdance.

Embryofields - your biggest problem might be living down the Bollywood stereotype.  Unless, of course, you can sing and dance...

22:12
Mar 24


Aluang Anak Bayang

Abangan

posts 5

13

If you are a blackie, then you must be popular.  We expect Blackie to be good in break dancing and play basketball. 

With Embryofields, he will be treated as one of us because SE Asians are used to living side by side with Indians. 

@ Lairedion,

Re "In Indonesia, those who bobble their head while talking"

Don't think Embryo will take it to heart.  Indians are can-do and easy going people.  I grew up with them. 

23:50
Mar 24


Suryo Perkoso

Santri

posts 61

14

Aluang Anak Bayang said:

If you are a blackie, then you must be popular.  We expect Blackie to be good in break dancing and play basketball. 

With Embryofields, he will be treated as one of us because SE Asians are used to living side by side with Indians. 

@ Lairedion,

Re "In Indonesia, those who bobble their head while talking"

Don't think Embryo will take it to heart.  Indians are can-do and easy going people.  I grew up with them. 


I knew it. You look just like Sri Anoop Ganeriwal Sahib.

6:34
Mar 25


Burung Koel

Santri

posts 23

15

If you are a blackie, then you must be popular.  We expect Blackie to be good in break dancing and play basketball.

Or at drumming - yeah, I've heard them all.  Although I really was good at basketball (up to state level).  I come from a mixed race family, so often confuse people.  In Indonesia, people seem genuinely interested in trying to work out where I'm from.  NB: although I believe there's no such thing as race anyway, as I've said here on other threads.

The positive thing for embryofields is that no matter what he looks like, the bemo drivers in Kuta will still treat him exactly the same as they would all foreigners. "Transporrrrrt?" I like Bali for that, and a host of other reasons.Smile

15:03
Mar 25


firman

Abangan

posts 1

16

Embarassed

17:55
Mar 25


Suryo Perkoso

Santri

posts 61

17

Patung said:

Oh gawd now we can see you up close….I strongly doubt embroyofields acts like an Indian, bobbing head and all, funny accent, I bet he acts like a lad from the UK….



And what might that mean?

17:56
Mar 25


Suryo Perkoso

Santri

posts 61

18

Burung Koel said:

If you are a blackie, then you must be popular.  We expect Blackie to be good in break dancing and play basketball.

Or at drumming - yeah, I've heard them all.  Although I really was good at basketball (up to state level).  I come from a mixed race family, so often confuse people.  In Indonesia, people seem genuinely interested in trying to work out where I'm from.  NB: although I believe there's no such thing as race anyway, as I've said here on other threads.

The positive thing for embryofields is that no matter what he looks like, the bemo drivers in Kuta will still treat him exactly the same as they would all foreigners. "Transporrrrrt?" I like Bali for that, and a host of other reasons.Smile


Is there no racism anymore then?

19:24
Mar 25


Burung Koel

Santri

posts 23

19

There's still racism, it's just that race is a cultural construct.  It's not genetic - our human DNA is so mixed up it's hard to tell where anyone comes from by looking at their chromosomes.  The furtherest relative on Earth from you would only be a 32nd cousin.  Mitochondrial DNA shows that we have all descended from about 6 to 8 original females ('Eves').

What 'race' is Tiger Woods, for example, or my kids for that matter?  Racism is something invented and used by people to define the 'other', the 'stranger' or the 'outsider'.

11:21
Jun 13


Mas Fred

Abangan

posts 9

20

I'm a white English chap (and a Muslim) so I'm a bule (Bule gila Grin) but, unless you are white, you don't qualify for the title.

Just asked my brother in law who says that Mr Polas from Bangladesh who lives here isn't a bule.


Sorry mate. Looks like you are stuffed for being a bule but I suspect, if you popped over here, you would get the same warm welcome I get.

There may be racism in some ways here but it's not the same concept as that idiot Adolf Griffin and his white supremasist rubbish.


I really love living here and the people are great.




RSS
RSS feed
Email

Copyright Indonesia Matters 2006-10
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact