11 Comments on “Political Ads, PKS”

1. HeavenlySword Says:
   November 5th, 2008 at 3:55 am

   Ah yes, controversy.. Indonesia is the land of controversy..

2. Sylvester Says:
   November 5th, 2008 at 4:16 am

   Everyone knows the PKS are Wahabi, but Hasyim Asyhari was Sunni

   No wonder if PKS supports Arabisation, pedhophile, and Islamic radicalism in Indonesia.

3. Toni Says:
   November 5th, 2008 at 10:59 am

   Hi there

   Any one of you, would you mind to comment the ads? What are they talking about? Sorry so much, I don’t understand the language although I would like to know if they are common political ads or are inciting against something/somebody, etc. I mean, I would like you to make a comment about the messages

   Thank you

4. David Says:
   November 5th, 2008 at 9:26 pm

   I would like to know if they are common political ads or are inciting against something/somebody

   They are ordinary political ads, focused on the theme of leadership and youth. If they were inciting against anything, besides being extremely unlikely, it would also be illegal.

   ……..

   Although…it is kind of interesting to compare the television ads, the official ads, with that German branch video, which of course is unofficial, quite a different feel to it, with that err sort of Islamic sounding music in the background, and the drum beats or something at the start, the mass flag waving, etc…

5. munro Says:
   November 6th, 2008 at 12:22 pm

   Can we call those ads ‘Pembohongan Publik’?
   I remember other PKS ads trying to extend their influence to ‘non-Islamist’ voters.
   As if. The party’s still as radical as it has always been.

6. Iman Says:
   November 8th, 2008 at 11:16 am

   Why such ads make some people angry? or I may say and should say jeleous? He..he..

   PKS is full of educated young people and they are smart. I can imagine how their competitors think “why i didn’t think about that?” well, not everyone has a good idea, especially if their brain is only about power and power.

   ‘pembohongan publik’ ? huek …bee cool man…see it one or thousand more time, which part is ‘pembohongan publik’? Don’t be too emotional…it just political ads man…and it turns out to be very successful……plus with all the comments that even make these ads become very very popular

   No hard feeling….:-)

7. rani Says:
   November 8th, 2008 at 2:11 pm

   I think Ipang Wahid still did these ads? PDIP and whatever parties Megawati’s sisters are in should protest too for the use of Soekarno figure. And PBB should protest too for the use of Natsir figure.

8. Iman Says:
   November 8th, 2008 at 8:31 pm

   Menurut sejarahwan Lembaga Ilmu Pengetahuan (LIPI) Asvi Warman Adam, tidak ada masalah dalam iklan politik PKS yang kini kerap lalu lalang di layar kaca itu. Hal itu karena, kedua tokoh yang muncul adalah pahlawan nasional.

   “Itu ikon pahlawan nasional, itu nggak masalah. Boleh dipakai siapa saja,” kata Asvi kepada detikcom, Jumat (31/10/2008).

   Asvi menilai, tampilnya tokoh nasional di dalam iklan politik sangat positif. Anak-anak dan masyarakat, dapat belajar sejarah dari iklan.

   “Kan tidak semua tokoh nasional diajarkan dalam pelajaran sejarah sekolah. Jadi saya mendukung sekali dan kalau bisa malah ditambah,” katanya.

   “Nothing wrong with the ads. They are national heroes, whoever may use them” Asvi (reseacher from LIPI) told detikcom. Asvi views the presence of national heroes in the political ads very positively. “Our children and our people are able to learn about our history through the ads”. “Not all national heroes were introduced in our school. So I support (the ads) and please create more ads like this if possible”

   So, still wanna protest this ads? Better be prepared with strong basis and not just jeleousy type of comment.

   I heard that PDIP is OK with ads, he…he…this is whether they are now being more rational and balanced or ….. as they are now hoping for coalition ..its time to be nice with PKS…

9. monyetmerah Says:
   November 14th, 2008 at 6:54 am

   Ah yes, controversy.. Indonesia is the land of controversy..

   Indonesia is the land of Hypocrisy

10. sholeh Says:
    December 23rd, 2008 at 9:26 pm

    Smart Party, Smart Think, and Smart ads.

11. agustio Says:
    December 28th, 2008 at 3:01 pm

    It’s not only political ads, but political strategy. To make people choose PKS. But, it’s normal. There is no false.

Your view on “Political Ads, PKS” :

Name

Email address

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail.